hpas 2020 environment

HPAS 2020 Environment & Ecology Topic-Wise Solutions

HPAS 2020 Environment & Ecology Solutions

Question 47

Desertification leads to decline in ___________

  • (a) Industrial productivity
  • (b) Agricultural productivity
  • (c) Biological productivity
  • (d) Human productivity
Correct Answer: (c) Biological productivity
💡 Relevant Detailed Explanation
1. Concept Explanation

Desertification is officially defined (UNCCD, 1994) as land degradation in arid, semi-arid, and dry sub-humid areas (“drylands”) resulting from climatic variations and human activities. The word to focus on is “biological” — desertification is not primarily about industry, or people in general, or even farming alone; it is about the land’s overall capacity to sustain living biomass: natural vegetation, soil micro-organisms, wildlife habitat, and crops together. As vegetation cover thins, soil organic matter and moisture-holding capacity fall, and the land’s ability to support any form of life declines — this composite decline is what “biological productivity” refers to.

Global bodies such as the UN and encyclopaedic sources consistently describe desertification using this exact phrase — “reduction in the biological productivity of drylands” — which is why it is the most precise and exam-safe answer whenever this concept is tested in any form.

2. Option-wise Analysis
  • (a) Industrial productivity — ❌ Incorrect. Desertification is a land/ecosystem degradation process; it does not directly measure or target industrial output, though industries dependent on land-based raw material could feel indirect effects.
  • (b) Agricultural productivity — ❌ Incorrect (the common trap). Farm yields genuinely do fall, which is what makes this option tempting, but it is narrower than the actual definition, which covers forests, grazing land, and wildlife habitat as well — not crops alone.
  • (c) Biological productivity — ✅ Correct. Matches the internationally accepted definition exactly: desertification is the decline in the land’s overall biological (life-supporting) productivity.
  • (d) Human productivity — ❌ Incorrect. Not a standard ecological term; a vague, non-technical distractor with no defined meaning in this context.
3. Exam Tips & Quick Recall
  • One-line answer to memorise: “Desertification = decline in biological productivity of drylands” (UNCCD, 1994 definition).
  • Main causes: recurring drought/climatic variability + human pressure — overgrazing, deforestation, overcultivation, and unsustainable irrigation (leading to salinization).
  • India context: worst-affected states are Rajasthan, Gujarat, Punjab, Haryana, and parts of Maharashtra/Karnataka; India has committed to Land Degradation Neutrality (LDN) targets under UNCCD.
  • Don’t confuse desertification (a degradation process) with the literal spread/expansion of existing deserts — the two are not the same thing.
Question 48

Where are the level of erosion highest?

  • (a) Monsoon Asia climate
  • (b) Tropical Asia climate
  • (c) Tropical Savannah climate
  • (d) Tropical Steppe climate
Correct Answer: (b) Tropical Asia climate
💡 Relevant Detailed Explanation
1. Concept Explanation

The intensity of water erosion in any region is chiefly governed by rainfall erosivity — how much rain falls, how intensely, and how concentrated it is in time — combined with slope, vegetation cover, and soil erodibility. Tropical/Monsoon Asia (covering South, Southeast, and much of East Asia) is the world’s classic example of extreme rainfall concentration: a very large share of the year’s rainfall arrives in just three to four monsoon months, striking slopes that have, over centuries, been heavily deforested and brought under cultivation to support very dense populations.

This specific combination — high-intensity seasonal downpours, reduced natural vegetation cover, and steep relief across large parts of the region (Himalayas, Western Ghats, Southeast Asian highlands) — is why climatic-geomorphology classifications (building on frameworks such as Peltier’s morphogenetic regions, which link rainfall/temperature regimes to dominant geomorphic processes) rank tropical monsoon Asia among the climatic zones with the highest rates of fluvial (water-driven) erosion on Earth, well above zones where rainfall is lighter or more evenly spread across the year.

2. Option-wise Analysis
  • (a) Monsoon Asia climate — ❌ Incorrect as keyed, though closely related. This describes essentially the same monsoon-dominated belt, and some texts use “Monsoon Asia” and “Tropical Asia” loosely as synonyms — but this question’s answer key treats “Tropical Asia” as the precise term being tested, so use that exact wording in your answer.
  • (b) Tropical Asia climate — ✅ Correct. Highest levels of erosion due to intensely concentrated monsoon rainfall acting on deforested, densely cultivated, often steep terrain.
  • (c) Tropical Savannah climate — ❌ Incorrect. Savannah regions also have a wet-dry seasonal rhythm, but total rainfall and rainfall intensity are generally lower than monsoon Asia, and grass cover offers more protective ground cover, keeping erosion comparatively moderate.
  • (d) Tropical Steppe climate — ❌ Incorrect. Steppe (semi-arid) regions receive low total rainfall, so while wind erosion can be notable there, water-driven erosion — the biggest contributor to global erosion totals — stays limited simply because there isn’t enough rain to drive it.
3. Exam Tips & Quick Recall
  • Memorise the driver, not just the label: erosion intensity ≈ rainfall concentration/intensity + slope − protective vegetation cover.
  • Rough ranking to recall: Monsoon/Tropical Asia (highest — intense seasonal rain + human pressure) > Savannah (moderate — wet-dry but grass-protected) > Steppe/semi-arid (lower water erosion, wind erosion instead) > dense equatorial rainforest (“selva,” where thick canopy cover suppresses erosion despite very high rainfall).
  • Link to the Himalayas: young, tectonically active mountains + monsoon intensity + deforestation together make the Himalayan belt one of the most erosion- and landslide-prone regions on Earth — a frequently tested application of this same idea.
Question 49

Deforestation adversely affects the ________.

  • (a) Geomophology
  • (b) Pedology
  • (c) Cryology
  • (d) Hydrology
Correct Answer: (d) Hydrology
💡 Relevant Detailed Explanation
1. Concept Explanation

Hydrology is the study of water — its distribution, movement, and cycling between the atmosphere, land surface, and underground stores (the hydrological cycle: precipitation → interception → infiltration → runoff → evapotranspiration → groundwater recharge). Forests act as natural regulators of every stage of this cycle: the canopy intercepts and softens rainfall before it hits the ground; root channels and leaf-litter humus keep soil porous, letting water soak in rather than run off; and trees continuously draw up groundwater and release it as vapour through transpiration, which feeds back into local and regional rainfall.

Deforestation strips away this regulating layer. Rain that once infiltrated now runs off rapidly over bare soil, so floods become flashier and more severe, while less water percolates down to recharge aquifers — meaning rivers that depended on that groundwater for their dry-season “baseflow” start running low between rains. Reduced transpiration also disrupts local moisture recycling and can measurably lower regional rainfall over time. All of this falls squarely within hydrology, making it the most directly and immediately affected discipline.

2. Option-wise Analysis
  • (a) Geomorphology — ❌ Incorrect. The study of landforms is affected only indirectly and over a longer timescale (e.g., new gullies or ravines forming from unchecked runoff) — a downstream consequence of the hydrological disruption, not the primary effect.
  • (b) Pedology — ❌ Incorrect. Soil science is genuinely affected (nutrient loss, structural collapse, erosion), but this too is largely a secondary consequence driven by the change in how water moves over and through the soil.
  • (c) Cryology — ❌ Incorrect. The study of ice, snow, and frozen ground is unrelated to deforestation in the general (non-polar, non-high-alpine) sense being tested here.
  • (d) Hydrology — ✅ Correct. Deforestation’s most direct, immediate, and widely-taught impact is on the water cycle — rainfall interception, infiltration, groundwater recharge, and river discharge patterns.
3. Exam Tips & Quick Recall
  • Learn the chain, not just the label: canopy interception → infiltration → groundwater recharge → stream baseflow. Deforestation breaks this chain at every link.
  • Consequences worth listing in a descriptive answer: increased flash flooding, reduced dry-season river flow, greater river/reservoir siltation, and altered local rainfall patterns.
  • Distinguish clearly from Pedology (soil) and Geomorphology (landforms) — both matter, but they are secondary/downstream effects, not the primary one this question is testing.
Question 50

Desertification often occurs in ________.

  • (a) Polar areas
  • (b) Hot desert areas
  • (c) Cold weather season
  • (d) Arunchal Pradesh
Correct Answer: (b) Hot desert areas
💡 Relevant Detailed Explanation
1. Concept Explanation

Desertification is, by definition, a dryland phenomenon — it develops in and around hot, arid, semi-arid, and dry sub-humid climatic zones, where rainfall is naturally scarce, vegetation cover is thin to begin with, and ecosystems have little buffer against added stress. When such fragile land is pushed further by drought, overgrazing, deforestation, or unsustainable irrigation, it tips into desert-like conditions. This is why the process is strongly associated with hot desert climatic belts and their margins, rather than with any other climate type.

This question is really testing whether you can correctly place desertification within its climatic setting against three clearly contrasting distractors — a cold/polar climate, a “season” (not a climate or region at all), and a genuinely wet Indian state — rather than testing a fine technical point.

2. Option-wise Analysis
  • (a) Polar areas — ❌ Incorrect. Cold/polar regions face their own distinct degradation issues (permafrost thaw, tundra disturbance), which are not classified as desertification.
  • (b) Hot desert areas — ✅ Correct. Desertification is fundamentally tied to hot, dry (arid-to-semi-arid) climatic regions and the fragile margins around them.
  • (c) Cold weather season — ❌ Incorrect. A “season” is not a climatic region at all — desertification is described in terms of climate/geography, not a time of year, so this option is a category mismatch.
  • (d) Arunchal Pradesh — ❌ Incorrect. Arunachal Pradesh is among India’s wettest, most densely forested states (heavy monsoon rainfall); it is effectively the opposite of desertification-prone terrain, included here purely as an obvious distractor.
3. Exam Tips & Quick Recall
  • One-liner: Desertification = a hot, dryland (arid/semi-arid) process; it is most active at the fragile margins of existing deserts, not deep within already-barren hyper-arid cores.
  • India’s desertification hotspots: Rajasthan (most affected), Gujarat, Punjab, Haryana, and parts of Maharashtra/Karnataka — all in the hot, semi-arid west and northwest.
  • Contrast for revision: high-rainfall, densely forested states like Arunachal Pradesh, Meghalaya, or Kerala face different land-degradation problems (landslides, slope erosion) rather than desertification.
Question 51

Accelerated erosion chiefly occurs in ________.

  • (a) Mountains
  • (b) Plains
  • (c) Valleys
  • (d) Plateaus
Correct Answer: (a) Mountains
💡 Relevant Detailed Explanation
1. Concept Explanation

Geographers distinguish “geological” (or “normal”) erosion — a slow, natural process that keeps pace with new soil formation and causes no net soil loss over time — from “accelerated erosion,” where the rate of soil loss is abnormally speeded up, usually by human activity, and outpaces the rate at which new soil can form. The single biggest natural control on how fast runoff can detach and carry away soil is slope: the steeper the gradient, the greater the velocity and kinetic energy of flowing water, and the more soil it can strip per rainfall event.

Mountains combine several worsening factors at once: steep gradients, thin/fragile soils sitting directly over bedrock, and — across much of the world, including the Himalayan and North-Eastern hill regions of India — heavy human pressure from deforestation, shifting (jhum) cultivation, terracing, road-building, and grazing that strips away the protective vegetation these slopes depend on. This combination is why accelerated erosion (gully erosion, landslides, high sediment loads in mountain streams) is chiefly concentrated in mountainous terrain rather than gentler landscapes.

2. Option-wise Analysis
  • (a) Mountains — ✅ Correct. Steep slopes, fragile soils, and widespread deforestation/unscientific cultivation on hillsides together produce the highest rates of accelerated, human-induced erosion.
  • (b) Plains — ❌ Incorrect. Low gradients give runoff far less erosive energy; where erosion does occur on plains it tends to be gradual sheet erosion, not the abrupt, “accelerated” gully/landslide type this question is asking about.
  • (c) Valleys — ❌ Incorrect. River valleys are frequently net depositional (aggradation) zones — they receive sediment eroded from the surrounding higher ground rather than being the chief source of that erosion.
  • (d) Plateaus — ❌ Incorrect. Plateaus can suffer erosion at their edges (e.g., ravine formation) but generally at lower intensity than the steep, high-relief slopes of young mountain systems.
3. Exam Tips & Quick Recall
  • Core principle to remember: steeper slope → greater erosive energy of runoff → higher (accelerated) erosion rate.
  • Indian examples worth citing in descriptive answers: jhum/shifting cultivation and deforestation in the North-Eastern hill states; slope destabilisation from deforestation and construction in the Western Ghats and Himalayan foothills.
  • Remember the contrast: mountains are net erosion-source zones, while plains/valleys downstream are often net sediment-receiving (depositional) zones.
Question 90

Statement 1: The amount of usable energy remains constant as it is passed from one trophic level to another.
Statement 2: The energy within an ecosystem is constant and never changes.

  • (a) Both Statement 1 and Statement 2 are correct
  • (b) Both Statement 1 and Statement 2 are incorrect
  • (c) Statement 1 is correct and Statement 2 is incorrect
  • (d) Statement 1 is incorrect and Statement 2 is correct
Correct Answer: (b) Both Statement 1 and Statement 2 are incorrect
💡 Relevant Detailed Explanation
1. Concept Explanation

Energy flow through an ecosystem is governed by two linked principles. First, the Ten Percent Law (Lindeman’s Trophic Efficiency Rule): at each transfer from one trophic level to the next (producer → herbivore → carnivore, and so on), only around 10% of the energy stored at one level is typically passed on as usable energy to the next. The remaining roughly 90% is lost — chiefly as heat released during respiration, plus energy spent on movement, growth, and reproduction, and energy locked in undigested or excreted matter. This progressive loss is why food chains rarely run beyond four or five trophic levels, and why energy pyramids are always upright, narrowing sharply toward the top.

Second, energy flow through an ecosystem is unidirectional (one-way), unlike nutrients. Matter — carbon, nitrogen, water, phosphorus, and so on — is recycled again and again through biogeochemical cycles and reused by the ecosystem. Energy cannot be recycled in the same way: once solar energy is captured by producers and passed along the food chain, it is progressively degraded to low-grade heat and lost to the surroundings at every step, per the second law of thermodynamics. This is precisely why an ecosystem needs a continuous, fresh input of sunlight to keep functioning — its energy budget is a one-way flow-through, never a fixed or self-contained quantity.

2. Statement-wise & Option Analysis
  • Statement 1 — ❌ Incorrect. “Usable energy remains constant” directly contradicts the Ten Percent Law: usable energy decreases sharply — not remains constant — at every trophic transfer.
  • Statement 2 — ❌ Incorrect. Energy within an ecosystem is not “constant and never changes”: it is continuously input via photosynthesis and continuously lost as heat through respiration, flowing through the system rather than being cycled or fixed like matter.

Since both underlying statements are false, the four combined answer options can now be evaluated directly:

  • (a) Both Statement 1 and Statement 2 are correct — ❌ Incorrect. Both statements individually fail, as shown above.
  • (b) Both Statement 1 and Statement 2 are incorrect — ✅ Correct. Matches the analysis: neither the “constant transfer” claim nor the “constant/unchanging energy” claim holds true.
  • (c) Statement 1 is correct and Statement 2 is incorrect — ❌ Incorrect. Statement 1 itself is false, so this combination cannot be right.
  • (d) Statement 1 is incorrect and Statement 2 is correct — ❌ Incorrect. Statement 2 itself is false, so this combination cannot be right either.
3. Exam Tips & Quick Recall
  • Two pillars to memorise: Lindeman’s 10% Law (efficiency of energy transfer) + unidirectional (one-way) flow of energy vs. the cyclical flow of nutrients.
  • Common trap: don’t confuse “energy is conserved” (true, in the strict first-law-of-thermodynamics sense — energy is never destroyed, only changes form) with “energy remains constant/usable within the ecosystem” (false — from an ecological productivity standpoint, it is steadily degraded to unusable heat and lost from the living system).
  • Related terms worth revising alongside this: Gross Primary Productivity (GPP) vs Net Primary Productivity (NPP), and why ecological pyramids of energy are always upright and never inverted.

Leave a Comment