hpas 2017 history

HPAS 2017 History Topic-Wise Solutions

HPAS 2017 History Topic-Wise Solutions

Question 46

Montague-Chelmsford Reforms were introduced in India in the year:

  • (a) 1881
  • (b) 1902
  • (c) 1909
  • (d) 1919
Correct Answer: (d) 1919
πŸ’‘ Detailed Explanation

The correct answer is (d) 1919. The Montagu-Chelmsford Reforms formed the basis of the Government of India Act, 1919.

The reforms are named after Edwin Samuel Montagu, the Secretary of State for India, and Lord Chelmsford, the Viceroy of India.

Their constitutional background lay in the Montagu Declaration of 20 August 1917, which announced the British government’s policy of progressively developing self-governing institutions and responsible government in India.

The most famous feature of the 1919 constitutional reforms was the introduction of dyarchy in the provinces. Provincial subjects were divided into Reserved and Transferred subjects.

Reserved subjects remained under the Governor and his executive councillors, while transferred subjects were administered by Indian ministers responsible to the provincial legislature.

πŸ” Explanation of Every Option
(a) 1881 β€” Incorrect. The year 1881 is important in Indian administrative history because it saw the first regular synchronous all-India census. It is unrelated to the Montagu-Chelmsford constitutional reforms.
(b) 1902 β€” Incorrect. There was no Montagu-Chelmsford constitutional reform in 1902. Lord Curzon was Viceroy during this period.
(c) 1909 β€” Incorrect. 1909 is associated with the Indian Councils Act, 1909, popularly called the Morley-Minto Reforms. These reforms introduced separate electorates for Muslims.
(d) 1919 β€” Correct. The Montagu-Chelmsford proposals were embodied in the Government of India Act, 1919.
πŸ“Š Constitutional Reforms Comparison
Reform / ActYearKey Feature
Morley-Minto Reforms1909Separate electorates for Muslims
Montagu Declaration1917Promise of progressive responsible government
Montagu-Chelmsford Reforms1919Dyarchy in provinces
Government of India Act1935Provincial autonomy; proposed federation
πŸ“š Reserved vs Transferred Subjects
CategoryExamplesControlled By
ReservedFinance, police, law and order, major revenue mattersGovernor and Executive Council
TransferredEducation, health, agriculture, local self-governmentIndian ministers responsible to legislature
⚠️ Exam Traps / Don’t Confuse: 1909 = Morley-Minto; 1919 = Montagu-Chelmsford; 1935 = provincial autonomy. Provincial dyarchy began under the 1919 Act and was abolished under the 1935 constitutional scheme.

🧠 Memory Trick

β€œ19–19 = two 19s β†’ two parts β†’ Dyarchy.” Remember Government of India Act 1919.

πŸ”„ Similar Question

Which system was introduced in the provinces by the Government of India Act, 1919?

  1. Provincial autonomy
  2. Dyarchy
  3. Separate electorates for the first time
  4. Complete responsible government

Correct Answer: (B) Dyarchy

Exam Connection: This tests the most important provision of the reforms asked in the original question.

Question 47

Dr. B.R. Ambedkar was born at:

  • (a) Poona
  • (b) Bombay
  • (c) Mhow
  • (d) Satara
Correct Answer: (c) Mhow
πŸ’‘ Detailed Explanation

The correct answer is (c) Mhow. Dr. Bhimrao Ramji Ambedkar was born on 14 April 1891 at Mhow, a military cantonment near Indore in present-day Madhya Pradesh.

Mhow has since been officially renamed Dr. Ambedkar Nagar. His father, Ramji Maloji Sakpal, served in the British Indian Army.

Although Ambedkar was born at Mhow, his family later moved to Satara, where part of his early education took place. This makes Satara a common distractor.

Ambedkar later studied at Elphinstone College, received higher education at Columbia University, and studied economics and law in London.

πŸ” Explanation of Every Option
(a) Poona β€” Incorrect. Pune was important in Ambedkar’s later political life, especially because the Poona Pact of 1932 was concluded there, but it was not his birthplace.
(b) Bombay β€” Incorrect. Bombay was important in Ambedkar’s education and public career. He attended Elphinstone College and later carried out major political and legal activity in Bombay.
(c) Mhow β€” Correct. Ambedkar was born at Mhow on 14 April 1891.
(d) Satara β€” Incorrect. Ambedkar spent part of his childhood and schooling in Satara after his family moved there, but he was not born there.
πŸ“š B.R. Ambedkar β€” High-Yield Facts
FactExam-Relevant Detail
Born14 April 1891, Mhow
Higher educationColumbia University; London School of Economics
OrganisationBahishkrit Hitakarini Sabha, 1924
Political partyIndependent Labour Party, 1936
ConstitutionChairman of Drafting Committee
Independent IndiaFirst Law Minister
ConversionEmbraced Buddhism in 1956
⚠️ Exam Trap: Mhow = birthplace; Satara = childhood/schooling connection; Bombay = education and political/legal career; Poona = Poona Pact, 1932.

🧠 Memory Trick

β€œAmbedkar began at MHOW.” Think: Mhow = Meeting point of his life.

πŸ”„ Similar Question

The Poona Pact of 1932 was concluded between Mahatma Gandhi and representatives led by:

  1. B.R. Ambedkar
  2. Jyotiba Phule
  3. Jagjivan Ram
  4. Periyar

Correct Answer: (A) B.R. Ambedkar

Exam Connection: Poona appears as a distractor in the original question and is actually connected with an important event in Ambedkar’s life.

Question 48

Which of the following leaders had worked for tribal upliftment?

  • (a) Mahatma Gandhi
  • (b) A.V. Thakkar
  • (c) Dr. B.R. Ambedkar
  • (d) Jagjivan Ram
Correct Answer: (b) A.V. Thakkar
πŸ’‘ Detailed Explanation

The correct answer is (b) A.V. Thakkar. Amritlal Vithaldas Thakkar, popularly known as Thakkar Bapa, was a social worker especially associated with work among tribal communities and other marginalized groups.

He was born on 29 November 1869 in Bhavnagar, Gujarat. After working as an engineer, he increasingly devoted himself to social service.

One of his most important initiatives was the Bhil Seva Mandal, established to promote education, welfare and social development among Bhil communities.

He was also associated with the Servants of India Society and later became an important office-bearer of the Harijan Sevak Sangh. His lifelong social work gave him the affectionate title β€œThakkar Bapa.”

πŸ” Explanation of Every Option
(a) Mahatma Gandhi β€” Not the specific answer. Gandhi worked extensively against untouchability and for rural and marginalized communities, and his constructive programme included social uplift. However, the personality especially identified in competitive examinations with dedicated tribal welfare work is Thakkar Bapa.
(b) A.V. Thakkar β€” Correct. Thakkar Bapa devoted a major part of his public life to the welfare and education of tribal and marginalized communities.
(c) Dr. B.R. Ambedkar β€” Incorrect for this specific question. Ambedkar’s principal political and social work focused on ending caste discrimination, securing civil rights, representation and equality for Scheduled Castes and other disadvantaged groups.
(d) Jagjivan Ram β€” Incorrect. Jagjivan Ram was a prominent freedom fighter, Congress leader and post-Independence minister who strongly advocated social equality and the rights of disadvantaged communities, but he is not the figure specifically identified with tribal upliftment here.
πŸ“š Thakkar Bapa β€” High-Yield Facts
  • Full name: Amritlal Vithaldas Thakkar.
  • Born: 29 November 1869, Bhavnagar.
  • Popular name: Thakkar Bapa.
  • Major field: welfare of tribal and marginalized communities.
  • Important association: Bhil Seva Mandal.
  • Other association: Servants of India Society.
  • Harijan Sevak Sangh: served as an important office-bearer.
  • Book: Tribes of India.
⚠️ Exam Trap: Gokhale β†’ Servants of India Society founder, while Thakkar Bapa β†’ later member/social worker associated with tribal welfare. Do not confuse founder with prominent worker.

🧠 Memory Trick

β€œThakkar BAPA worked for tribal BHAI.” β†’ Thakkar Bapa = tribal welfare.

πŸ”„ Similar Question

A.V. Thakkar, popularly known as Thakkar Bapa, is especially associated with which organisation for tribal welfare?

  1. Bhil Seva Mandal
  2. Abhinav Bharat
  3. Khudai Khidmatgar
  4. Indian Association

Correct Answer: (A) Bhil Seva Mandal

Exam Connection: This tests the specific organization associated with Thakkar Bapa’s tribal welfare work.

Question 49

Which of the following leaders was never associated with the Indian National Congress?

  • (a) V.D. Savarkar
  • (b) Lala Lajpat Rai
  • (c) Vallabhbhai Patel
  • (d) S.C. Bose
Correct Answer: (a) V.D. Savarkar
πŸ’‘ Detailed Explanation

The expected answer is (a) V.D. Savarkar. Vinayak Damodar Savarkar is principally associated with revolutionary organizations such as Abhinav Bharat and, in his later political career, with the Hindu Mahasabha.

In contrast, Lala Lajpat Rai, Vallabhbhai Patel and Subhas Chandra Bose all held significant roles within the Indian National Congress at different stages of their careers.

Savarkar founded Abhinav Bharat in 1904. He was arrested in connection with revolutionary activity and was sentenced to transportation and imprisonment in the Cellular Jail. After restrictions on him were lifted, he became closely associated with the Hindu Mahasabha and served as its president for several years.

πŸ” Explanation of Every Option
(a) V.D. Savarkar β€” Correct. In standard examination classification, Savarkar’s organized political career is associated with revolutionary nationalism and the Hindu Mahasabha, rather than leadership within the INC.
(b) Lala Lajpat Rai β€” Incorrect. Lajpat Rai was an important Congress nationalist and part of the Lal-Bal-Pal grouping. He presided over the Calcutta Special Session of the Congress in 1920.
(c) Vallabhbhai Patel β€” Incorrect. Patel was a major Congress leader, participated in Gandhian mass movements and later became independent India’s first Deputy Prime Minister and Home Minister.
(d) S.C. Bose β€” Incorrect. Subhas Chandra Bose was twice elected Congress presidentβ€”at Haripura in 1938 and again at Tripuri in 1939. He later resigned from the Congress presidency and founded the Forward Bloc.
πŸ“Š Leader–Organisation Comparison
LeaderMajor Organisation / AssociationHigh-Yield Fact
V.D. SavarkarAbhinav Bharat; Hindu MahasabhaAbhinav Bharat founded in 1904
Lala Lajpat RaiIndian National CongressLal-Bal-Pal; Congress Special Session, 1920
Vallabhbhai PatelIndian National CongressBardoli Satyagraha; Congress organisation
Subhas Chandra BoseINC; later Forward BlocCongress president 1938 and 1939
⚠️ Exam Trap: Subhas Bose left the Congress later, but that does not mean he was never associated with it. He had been one of its most prominent leaders and served as Congress president.

🧠 Exam Shortcut

Among these four names: Lajpat Rai + Patel + Bose = clear INC careers. That leaves Savarkar.

πŸ”„ Similar Question

Subhas Chandra Bose was elected president of the Indian National Congress at Haripura in:

  1. 1935
  2. 1936
  3. 1938
  4. 1940

Correct Answer: (C) 1938

Exam Connection: This reinforces why Bose cannot be the answer to the original question.

Question 50

Which of the following was not a socialist leader?

  • (a) Ram Manohar Lohiya
  • (b) Jaiprakash Narain
  • (c) S.C. Bose
  • (d) M.R. Jaiyakar
Correct Answer: (d) M.R. Jaiyakar
πŸ’‘ Detailed Explanation

The expected answer is (d) M.R. Jayakar. Mukund Ramrao Jayakar was primarily known as a lawyer, constitutionalist, political negotiator and public figure rather than as a leader of India’s socialist political current.

By contrast, Ram Manohar Lohia and Jayaprakash Narayan were central figures of organized Indian socialist politics.

Subhas Chandra Bose did not belong to exactly the same socialist organizational stream as Lohia and Jayaprakash Narayan, but his economic and political programme contained strong socialist and left-nationalist elements. He also formed the Forward Bloc in 1939.

πŸ” Explanation of Every Option
(a) Ram Manohar Lohiya β€” Socialist leader. Ram Manohar Lohia joined the Congress Socialist Party in 1934. He later became one of the leading thinkers and organizers of India’s socialist movement.
(b) Jaiprakash Narain β€” Socialist leader. Jayaprakash Narayan was one of the principal leaders of the Congress Socialist Party and played an important role in socialist politics before later emphasizing Sarvodaya and β€œTotal Revolution.”
(c) S.C. Bose β€” Not the expected answer. Bose represented a radical nationalist and left-oriented strand. He advocated extensive state planning and strong state intervention in economic development and later founded the Forward Bloc.
(d) M.R. Jaiyakar β€” Correct. M.R. Jayakar was a prominent jurist, constitutional politician and negotiator. He was associated at different times with bodies such as the Hindu Mahasabha and Swaraj Party but was not a principal leader of the socialist movement.
πŸ“š Congress Socialist Party β€” High Yield
  • Formed in 1934.
  • Worked initially as a socialist group within the Indian National Congress.
  • Acharya Narendra Dev was a major ideological leader.
  • Jayaprakash Narayan was one of its principal organizers.
  • Ram Manohar Lohia was another major socialist thinker and leader.
PersonMajor Association
Ram Manohar LohiaCongress Socialist Party; later Socialist Party
Jayaprakash NarayanCongress Socialist Party; socialist and later Sarvodaya politics
Subhas Chandra BoseRadical nationalism; Forward Bloc; state-planning orientation
M.R. JayakarLawyer, constitutional politician, negotiator
⚠️ Exam Trap: Do not assume that every left-leaning nationalist belonged to the Congress Socialist Party. Lohia and Jayaprakash had a direct CSP connection; Bose followed his own radical nationalist political trajectory.

🧠 Exam Shortcut

Lohia + JP = obvious Socialists. Bose had strong left-oriented politics. Jayakar = jurist/constitutionalist β†’ odd one out.

πŸ”„ Similar Question

The Congress Socialist Party was formed in which year?

  1. 1928
  2. 1930
  3. 1934
  4. 1939

Correct Answer: (C) 1934

Exam Connection: The organization provides the historical context for Lohia and Jayaprakash Narayan in the original question.

Question 51

Which of the following bills was drafted by Dr. B.R. Ambedkar as the first Law Minister of India?

  • (a) Hindu Code Bill
  • (b) Indian Code Bill
  • (c) Hindu Marriage Bill
  • (d) Human Rights Bill
Correct Answer: (a) Hindu Code Bill
πŸ’‘ Detailed Explanation

The correct answer is (a) Hindu Code Bill. After Independence, Dr. B.R. Ambedkar became India’s first Law Minister in 1947.

One of his most important legislative projects was the Hindu Code Bill, which sought major reforms in Hindu personal law concerning areas such as marriage, divorce, succession, inheritance and adoption.

The Bill encountered extensive opposition and was not enacted in the comprehensive form Ambedkar had supported during his tenure. The dispute surrounding the Bill was an important factor in his resignation from the Union Cabinet in 1951.

In the mid-1950s, several major separate laws were enacted that dealt with many of the subjects originally addressed by the proposed comprehensive code.

πŸ” Explanation of Every Option
(a) Hindu Code Bill β€” Correct. Ambedkar strongly supported and introduced the project of reforming and codifying Hindu personal law while serving as Law Minister.
(b) Indian Code Bill β€” Incorrect. There is no corresponding major legislation by this title associated with Ambedkar’s tenure as first Law Minister.
(c) Hindu Marriage Bill β€” Incorrect as the original comprehensive answer. Marriage was one part of the proposed Hindu Code Bill. A separate Hindu Marriage Act was ultimately enacted in 1955.
(d) Human Rights Bill β€” Incorrect. No legislation by this title is the measure being referred to in Ambedkar’s work as Law Minister.
πŸ“Š Later Hindu Personal-Law Legislation
LawYearMain Area
Hindu Marriage Act1955Marriage and divorce
Hindu Succession Act1956Inheritance and succession
Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act1956Minority and guardianship
Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act1956Adoption and maintenance
πŸ“š Ambedkar β€” Constitutional & Legal Facts
  • First Law Minister of independent India: 1947.
  • Chairman: Drafting Committee of the Constituent Assembly.
  • Drafting Committee constituted: 29 August 1947.
  • Constitution adopted: 26 November 1949.
  • Constitution came into force: 26 January 1950.
  • Resigned from Cabinet: 1951, with disagreement over the Hindu Code Bill among the important factors.
⚠️ Exam Trap: Hindu Code Bill was the broader reform project. Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 was one of the separate statutes enacted later. Do not treat the two names as identical.

🧠 Memory Trick

Remember the later sequence: Marriage 1955 β†’ Succession, Guardianship, Adoption & Maintenance 1956.

πŸ”„ Similar Question

Dr. B.R. Ambedkar resigned from the Union Cabinet in 1951 amid major disagreement over which legislative project?

  1. Hindu Code Bill
  2. Government of India Act
  3. Rowlatt Act
  4. Indian Councils Bill

Correct Answer: (A) Hindu Code Bill

Exam Connection: This tests the major political consequence of the legislative project asked about in the original question.

Leave a Comment